I’ve been thinking about Good Friday. Why do we call it Good Friday anyway?
A few weeks ago I began putting together a list of songs to choose from for our annual Good Friday service at Mars Hill Church in Seattle. Mostly hymns because hymns are good at the bloody and violent aspects of the cross, which is essential to the theme. Hymns are also really good at one other thing that, to me, seems out of place during the Good Friday service: Hope. Or, more clearly, the result of the finished work on the cross complete with the resurrection 3 days later. This is at the center of Christian hope: that Jesus lived a sinless life and conquered death and therefore has something of pure and true value to offer us. But focusing on the hope while trying to grasp the gravity of Jesus’ death may going too far if we’re trying to understand what happened on the 1st day.
The idea goes like this. We focus on the death of Christ, the devastating act it was, and the ensuing confusion that must have taken place directly after. I thought he was the Messiah!? But now he’s dead! We attempt to understand the loss. We mourn. We reflect. Some people cry. Some weep. Others internalize it. You know, we all respond differently. But then the band plays and leads us in songs that, no matter how bloody they are, seemingly always end in resurrection and hope!
Ordinarily, this is good.
But Good Friday is different.
I think we should leave devastated. Let down. Maybe even depressed. After all, that’s how the disciples left. “And all the crowds that had assembled for this spectacle, when they saw what had taken place, returned home beating their breasts. And all his acquaintances and the women who had followed him from Galilee stood at a distance watching these things.” (Luke 23:48-49) Not so much a hopeful image.
If the goal is to put ourselves in their shoes, then we need songs that end in death. We need songs that end in injustice, the killing of the innocent man. We need songs that highlight our participation in the crucifixion because, after all, if we have committed one sin, then Jesus died for it, and therefore was put on the cross by our own dirty hands.
We must think highly of Jesus’ death. It’s the only way we can truly rejoice on the 3rd day when we gather to celebrate His resurrection, restoring our hope, restoring our affection, and glorifying God like the angels do in heaven, “Praise and glory and wisdom and thanks and honor and power and strength be to our God forever and ever, amen.”